The Guide of Database Selection in 2025

Making your tech stack decision for 2025? The process is now simpler than ever.

Kyle ChungKyle Chung

TL;DR

There is no "one-size-fits-all" database. The skill of a modern developer is not in mastering a single database, but in knowing which tool to pull from the toolbox for the task at hand. Even in an AI supported workflow, these decisions are still essential for scaling products and services both efficiently and effectively.

By understanding the core strengths of each—Postgres for power, MySQL for reliability, MongoDB for flexibility, Redis for speed, and Supabase for velocity—you can build more robust, scalable, and successful applications.


Choosing Your Database in 2025: A Guide to PostgreSQL, MongoDB, Supabase, and More

Every great application is built on a solid foundation of data, but for developers, choosing the right database can feel like navigating a minefield. One wrong choice early on can lead to performance bottlenecks, development headaches, and a world of pain down the road. The landscape is vast, with a dizzying array of options, each claiming to be the best.

The truth is, there is no single "best" database. The real question is: What is the right database for your specific project?

This guide will demystify the most popular choices today. We'll explore the low-level architecture of titans like PostgreSQL and MySQL, understand the flexibility of NoSQL with MongoDB, feel the speed of Redis, and see how modern platforms like Supabase are changing the game. By the end, you'll have a clear framework for making the right decision for your next project.

Understanding the Main Categories of Database

Before we dive into specific names, let's understand the major families they belong to.

  • SQL (Relational Databases): Think of a collection of highly organized Excel spreadsheets with strict rules. Data is stored in tables with rows and columns, and relationships between tables are clearly defined. This structure ensures high data integrity and consistency, making it a reliable choice for predictable data.
  • NoSQL (Non-Relational Databases): Think of a flexible filing cabinet where you can store different types of documents without having to pre-define their structure. This category is incredibly diverse, including document stores (like MongoDB) and key-value stores (like Redis). It excels at handling large volumes of unstructured data and scaling out horizontally.
  • DBaaS (Database-as-a-Service): This isn't a new type of database but a modern way to use one. A DBaaS provider gives you a "database with batteries included"—they handle the server, setup, backups, and often add powerful layers on top like authentication and auto-generated APIs, letting you focus solely on building your application.

The Contenders: A Closer Look

Now let's get to know our players.

PostgreSQL: The Powerful and Extensible All-Rounder

PostgreSQL is a powerful, open-source database that operates on a client-server model, where a central "Postmaster" process manages incoming connections by creating separate processes for each user. This ensures stability and isolation. At its core, data is stored in files on your disk, organized into tables and sped up by indexes, much like a digital filing cabinet with a helpful card catalog. To handle many users at once without conflict, it cleverly uses a system called Multi-Version Concurrency Control (MVCC), which gives each user a consistent "snapshot" of the data, allowing for high concurrency without locking others out.

MySQL & MariaDB: The Reliable and Battle-Tested Workhorses

MySQL operates on a classic client-server architecture where the central server process manages all database instructions. Its key architectural feature is its pluggable storage engine model, which separates query processing from data storage. This allows you to choose different "storage engines" (like the popular, transaction-safe InnoDB) for different tables based on your needs. MariaDB, a community-driven fork of MySQL, shares this core architecture but continues to develop its own high-performance engines, making both databases incredibly versatile and reliable workhorses that power a massive portion of the web.

MongoDB: The King of Flexible, Document-Based Data

MongoDB is a leading NoSQL database that stores data in flexible, JSON-like documents using a binary-encoded format called BSON for efficiency. Instead of tables, data is organized into "collections" with no enforced schema, offering immense flexibility. To handle large datasets, MongoDB is built for horizontal scalability through "sharding," which partitions data across multiple servers. Its storage engine, WiredTiger, uses document-level concurrency control and in-memory caching to ensure high-performance read and write operations.

Redis: The In-Memory Speed Demon

Redis (Remote Dictionary Server) is an in-memory key-value store, meaning it primarily holds the entire dataset in your computer's RAM. This is the secret to its blazing-fast performance. Architecturally, Redis is single-threaded and uses an event loop to handle requests, efficiently managing concurrent clients without the overhead of multithreading. While it's more than a simple key-value store, supporting rich data structures like lists, sets, and hashes, its primary strength lies in its speed, making it an unparalleled choice for caching and real-time tasks.

Supabase: The Modern Backend-as-a-Service on Postgres

Supabase isn't a new database but a developer-friendly platform built directly on PostgreSQL. Every Supabase project is a dedicated Postgres instance, but with a powerful suite of open-source tools layered on top. This includes an authentication system that uses Postgres's own Row-Level Security, an API gateway that automatically generates RESTful APIs from your schema, and a real-time server that broadcasts database changes to subscribed clients. It gives you the power of Postgres with the convenience of a modern BaaS.

Head-to-Head: The Comparison Matrix

FeaturePostgreSQLMySQL/MariaDBMongoDBRedisSupabase
Data ModelRelational (SQL)Relational (SQL)NoSQL (Document)NoSQL (Key-Value)Relational (SQL)
Primary Use CaseComplex queries, data integrity, general purposeWeb apps, e-commerce, read-heavy tasksUnstructured data, big data, mobile appsCaching, sessions, real-time leaderboardsRapid development, MVPs, projects needing auth/APIs
ScalabilityVertical (strong), Horizontal (complex)Vertical (strong), Horizontal (complex)Horizontal (native)Horizontal (native)Vertical (managed)
SchemaEnforced & StrictEnforced & StrictFlexible & DynamicSchemalessEnforced & Strict
Developer ExperienceExcellent, but requires setupVery straightforward and widely supportedEasy to start, flexible schema is great for devsSimple API, very fastHighest. "Batteries-included" experience.

How to Choose Database: A Practical Decision Guide

So, which one is for you? Let's break it down by your needs.

  • If your data is highly structured and integrity is non-negotiable...
    • ...then start with PostgreSQL. Its robust feature set and adherence to SQL standards make it a safe and powerful bet for financial applications, scientific data, and any complex system where data consistency is king.
  • If you are building a traditional web application (like a blog or e-commerce site) and need something reliable and easy...
    • ...then MySQL or MariaDB are fantastic choices. They have a massive community, are easy to host, and are battle-tested by years of powering a huge portion of the web.
  • If your data is unstructured, evolves frequently, or you need to scale massively...
    • ...then MongoDB is your best friend. Its flexible document model is perfect for content management systems, IoT data, and applications where the data shape isn't known upfront.
  • If you need blazing-fast speed for caching, real-time stats, or managing user sessions...
    • ...then look no further than Redis. It is not meant to be your primary database, but as a lightning-fast layer on top of it, it is second to none.
  • If you want to build and launch a project as fast as possible without managing a backend...
    • ...then Supabase is the clear winner. It gives you the power of Postgres but handles the tedious parts like APIs, authentication, and real-time functions for you, making it ideal for startups, side-projects, and MVPs.

Deploy your Database with Zeabur

Why Choose Zeabur to host your database

Cost-Effective with Flexible Pricing

Zeabur uses a pay-as-you-go model that's perfect for databases, the $5 Developer plan allows users to only pay for what you actually use - no upfront costs for unused resources. The usage-based charges (memory, storage, bandwidth) also enable business owners to scale the database resources up or down based on demand. With Zeabur, you can expect a much more cost-effective way to manage your infra other than traditional fixed-pricing database hosts.

Effortless Operation & Management

One-click deployment makes database setup incredibly simple. Simply deploy choose and deploy all the popular database choices (PostgreSQL, MySQL, MongoDB, Redis), then manage the data service with Zeabur's intuitive dashboard for performance, connections, and resource usage monitor. We also handle automatic backups and maintenance for our users, without the need to understand complex server configuration or database administration.

Wide Database Variety

Our template library covers all your database needs, just like buffet! Simply choose the one fits into your need the most:

  • Relational: PostgreSQL, MySQL, MariaDB
  • NoSQL: MongoDB, CouchDB
  • In-memory: Redis, KeyDB
  • Specialized: InfluxDB, Neo4j, Supabase, PlanetScale
  • Self-hosted alternatives: Directus, Strapi, Appwrite

How to one-click deploy database with Zeabur

Deploy with Zeabur Agent (Recommended)

  • Initiate Deployment: The user starts the process of deploying Supabase on the Zeabur platform. The AI assistant confirms it has found the Supabase template and will auto-generate initial values for the username and domain prefix.

1. Initiating Supabase Deployment on Zeabur.png

  • Select Project: The user is prompted to choose which existing project to deploy Supabase to. A list of available projects is displayed.

2. Selecting a Project for Supabase Deployment.png

  • Create New Project: Instead of selecting an existing project, the user decides to create a new one for this deployment.

3. Opting to Create a New Project.png

  • Select Region: The user is then presented with a list of available geographical regions and cloud providers to host the new project and its services. They select "Hong Kong" on Amazon Web Services.

4. Choosing a Deployment Region.png

  • Deployment Confirmation: The AI assistant confirms that the new project has been created and the Supabase template deployment has been successfully initiated. It provides the final details, including the project name, region, username, and the full domain.

5. Successful Deployment Initiation and Details.png

  • View Services: The final image shows the user successfully navigated to their new "supabase-project" on the Zeabur dashboard. The "studio" service is running, and all the other Supabase services (like auth, kong, postgresql, etc.) are listed as part of the project.

6. Supabase Project and Services Running on Zeabur.png


Manual Setup with Pre-built Templates

Here is the step-by-step workflow illustrated by the images:

  • Navigate to Templates: The user is on the Zeabur website and navigates to the "Templates" section to find pre-configured application templates.

1. Navigating the Zeabur Platform.png

  • Search for Supabase: The user utilizes the search bar to specifically look for the "Supabase" template among the available options.

2. Searching for the Supabase Template.png

  • Select the Template: After finding the "Supabase (Instructions for update secrets)" template, the user clicks on it to view its details and initiate the deployment process.

4. Selecting the Supabase Deployment Template.png

  • Configure Deployment: A configuration modal appears, prompting the user to enter a desired Username and a Domain prefix for their Supabase instance.

5. Configuring Deployment Parameters for Supabase.png

  • Provide Details: The user fills in the required information, entering "username" and "supaaa" for the domain prefix, and the system confirms that the chosen domain is available.

6. Entering Username and Checking Domain Availability.png

  • Initiate Deployment: After confirming the details, the user starts the deployment. A status screen appears, showing the progress as each of the 10 services required by Supabase (such as kong, studio, postgresql) is provisioned.

7. Monitoring the Real-time Deployment Progress.png

  • Deployment Completion: Once all services are running, the user is taken to the project dashboard. The final view shows the "kong" service is active, and the full list of deployed Supabase services is visible on the left, indicating a successful deployment.

8. Successful Deployment and Viewing the Service Dashboard.png


Additional Resources